Skip to main content

Aiello trial under way Monday

July 30, 2012

The Main Courtroom at the Elk County Courthouse was near capacity Monday, with members of the public and witnesses arriving for the first day in the jury trial of Daniel Aiello, 27, of St. Marys, charged with over 100 counts of felony burglary in a spree that spanned 13 months and three counties.
For his alleged role in the crimes, Daniel Aiello is charged with the following: felony burglary; felony and misdemeanor theft by unlawful taking of moveable property; criminal conspiracy; and criminal mischief with damage to property through reckless, negligence, or intention.
In his opening argument Monday, Elk County District Attorney Bradley J. Kraus said the defendant had conspired with his brother, Mark Paul Kimes Aiello, in committing 66 counts of burglary at camps in Elk County, 30 in Cameron, and 15 in McKean County between December 2009 and January 2011.
Twenty-four owners of the area camps involved, some residing as far away as Hershey, Harrisburg, and Butler County, were present Monday, subpoenaed to provide their testimony in the trial.
Many testified that they discovered their camps had been burglarized via calls from friends, neighbors, or police, and each recounted what they had observed upon arriving at their camps following the incidents.
Witnesses described finding entryways pried open or kicked in and the inside of the camps ransacked, with drawers opened and emptied of their contents, furniture upended, and missing items ranging from loose change to antler mounts and taxidermied animals, power tools and a four-wheeler.
A number of witnesses recalled their camps being burglarized twice within a matter of weeks. In his testimony, Russ Braun of St. Marys, owner of a camp in Jones Twp., said he had heard about burglaries in the area and went to check on his camp the day after Christmas. When he arrived, he found the door ajar with signs of forced entry, as well as two sets of footprints in a quarter-inch of fresh snow.
Braun said his inspection of the interior revealed that a flat-screen television and power tools had been taken from inside the structure.
Braun contacted the Emporium-based Pennsylvania State Police and eventually re-secured the structure before leaving.
One week later, the day after New Year's Day, Braun's camp was again burglarized. This time, Braun said the entire doorjamb was demolished and the only item taken was a sign reading, "Welcome to the Cabin."
In testimony heard Monday, description of the damages varied from severe damage requiring repairs to little or no damage.
Additional testimony was received from dozens of camp owners, provided in the form of stipulations stating that the individual owned the camp in question, did not know the defendant, that Aiello did not have permission or reason to enter the camp, and that the camp suffered damage and missing items.
Kraus said the the locations of the camps involved were confirmed by Mark Paul Kimes Aiello, who identified each of them to Trooper Matthew Higgins of the Ridgway-based Pa. State Police.
According to Kraus, Kimes volunteered to go on a ride-along with Trooper Matthew Higgins of the Ridgway-based Pa. State Police, during which he pointed out the locations where he said he and Daniel Aiello had committed the burglaries.
Kraus said that Trooper Matthew Higgins of the Ridgway-based Pa. State Police Barracks had initially received information from Paul Kimes Jr., of Kane, father of Mark Paul Kimes Aiello and stepfather to Daniel Aiello, regarding the possibility of his sons' involvement in the burglaries.
Paul Kimes Jr. testified Monday that he was contacted by Higgins in late 2010 or early 2011 with the subject of the conversation being, "Daniel and the robberies taking place."
Kimes Jr. then agreed to meet with Higgins on Feb. 14, at which point Kimes Jr. said he told Higgins that Daniel Aiello had admitted to having committed "several robberies" with Mark Paul Kimes Aiello in Benezette and Highland Township.
"I told him they were dumb and going to get caught eventually," Kimes Jr. said.
Testimony from Daniel Aiello's brother, Mark Paul Kimes Aiello will be heard when the trial resumes Tuesday at 9 a.m.

Pick up a copy of the Tuesday, July 31, 2012 edition of The Ridgway Record for more.

Ridgway volleyball used strong serving to take a 3-0 (25-23, 25-17, 25-17) victory over Brockway...
Ridgway boys golf won 187-233 over St. Marys this afternoon as the Elkers honored their seniors....
A three-match losing streak came to an end for Ridgway boys soccer as the Elkers defeated...